Let us start by saying that we have been to Key West many times in the last seven years, and this has been our best experience yet. It started with check-in and lasted until (sadly) our check out. We spent two wonderful nights, and three fantastic days. Our greeting upon check-in was handled by Erika and Kate (Marjorie). What a... more

This hotel is very nice. We stayed for 4 nights just before the 4th of July. All the employees were extemely helpful and nice. We were in the main suite...a little expensive, but very nice. They even helped solve a parking problem. I highly recommend this hotel. more

Stayed at the Gardens in 2005 (right before hurricane Katrina!) and had looked forward to returning every day since. We finally got our wish last month, and the Gardens did not disappoint. Everyone on the staff is wonderful, particularly Cindy and Billy. We missed the cats that were there in 2005 and were sorry to hear that they had passed... more

Just got back from a wonderful stay at this hotel. We were greeted with champagne on our arrival by the front desk. The hospitaliaty was fantastic. Our room was beautiful with wood flooring, flat screen tv, very clean and decorative. The hotel was booked but it was so quiet we felt like the only guests. The continental breakfast was wonderful... more

Lovely, quiet hotel located just off Duval Street (the main street). The pool was small but clean and quiet. Breakfast was excellent, you have to try the cinnamon toast with maple syrup! And the complimentary iced tea while sunbathing around the pool was delicious! Room was a good size and very clean, although the fridge and coffee making facilities were... more

First, I've seen reviews about the bartender....I don't know if the guy was on vacation or something, but the bar was relatively unimpressive, especially with the plethora of establishments (and I don't mean Sloppy Joes) waiting for you on Duvall Street. Anyway, not a negative in my opinion, but I was expecting more. In terms of the hotel itself, the... more

My husband and I chose the Gardens Hotel and the Island City Hotel for our 4 nights in Key West in June 2008.Despite the rave reviews for the Gardens we found it to be nice but nothing to get excited about. Our room near the pool was VERY small with a small closet and no drawer space. The grounds should... more

Location, KATIE, Rooms, with parking, the entire package was better than expected. This is the best location for exploring all of Key West and its quiet, peaceful and the staff is great. We were there on a Sunday night and they had a Jazz Band at the Pool, which has a bar adjacent. Have traveled the world and this is... more

Based on this website, we booked a stay at The Gardens and were so pleased with everything! The staff goes out of their way to ensure that your stay is comfortable and pleasing in every way. The property is beautiful and kept immaculately. The breakfasts are sumptuous and the patio is a peaceful and cheerful place to start the day.... more